Key Points
- Washington State Supreme Court Justice Raquel Montoya-Lewis—the first Native American to serve on the court and the first Native American elected to statewide office in Washington—declined to seek re-election in 2026 and is stepping down from her Position 3 seat at the Temple of Justice in Olympia, with her term ending around the turn of the year (with Justice-elect Jaime Hawk taking office in January 2027).
- Appointed in December 2019 by then-Governor Jay Inslee (taking office in January 2020) and later winning a contested statewide race in 2020, Justice Montoya-Lewis—an enrolled member of the Pueblo of Isleta and descendant of the Pueblo of Laguna in New Mexico who holds a law degree and a Master of Social Work from the University of Washington—described her tenure’s “highs” as authoring majority opinions on issues important to her and its “lows” as carrying community expectations and experiencing isolation.
- She became the first Native American appellate judge to guide the application of the federal Indian Child Welfare Act in a randomly assigned majority opinion addressing what she wrote was “enacted to remedy the historical and persistent state-sponsored destruction of Native families and communities.”
- Internal court disagreements arose over traditions and protocols—including when Justice Montoya-Lewis added footnotes thanking her law clerks by name and issued an internal memo regarding a majority opinion upholding an aspect of the Climate Commitment Act—leading to concurring opinions by Justice Steven González and now-retired Justice Barbara Madsen.
- During her time on the court, justices also acted to repudiate a 1916 ruling in the case of Yakama Nation member Alec Towessnute concerning tribal fishing rights, following advocacy pushed by Justice Montoya-Lewis at the request of Mr Towessnute’s family and then-Attorney General Bob Ferguson, among others.
- Following her departure, Justice Montoya-Lewis plans to collaborate with the American Indian Law Center at the University of New Mexico to expand the pipeline of Native American law clerks and judges and hopes to write a family history memoir, while noting that the court will lose its only Native American member and expressing no prediction on how future justices—including her successor, King County Superior Court Judge Jaime Hawk—might rule on precedent such as the 1933 Culliton decision or a proposed “millionaire’s tax” on high earners.
Olympia (Evening Washington News) November 20, 2026 – Washington State Supreme Court Justice Raquel Montoya-Lewis, the first Native American to serve on the state’s highest court and the first Native American elected to statewide office in Washington, is stepping down after choosing not to run for re-election in 2026. Appointed by former Governor Jay Inslee and elected in a contested race in 2020, Justice Montoya-Lewis reflects on authoring landmark opinions, navigating isolation and protocol disputes over thanking law clerks, and the court’s 2020 repudiation of a 1916 tribal fishing rights ruling. She declines to predict how the court—which will transition to successor Judge Jaime Hawk—will address future cases such as a high-earner income tax.
- Key Points
- Why Is Justice Raquel Montoya-Lewis Leaving the Washington State Supreme Court?
- What Disagreements Over Court Traditions and Clerk Footnotes Emerged?
- How Did the Court Address the 1916 Alec Towessnute Fishing Rights Ruling?
- What Are Justice Montoya-Lewis’s Views on Precedent, Future Cases, and Her Next Steps?
- Background: Tribal Rights, Judicial Precedent, and Turnover on Washington’s High Court
- Predictions: How Could Justice Montoya-Lewis’s Departure Affect Tribal Communities, Legal Pipelines, and Future Court Rulings?
Why Is Justice Raquel Montoya-Lewis Leaving the Washington State Supreme Court?
Justice Raquel Montoya-Lewis is preparing to vacate her chambers at the Temple of Justice in Olympia after deciding not to seek re-election in 2026, bringing an end to her six-year term on the Washington State Supreme Court.
First appointed by then-Governor Jay Inslee in late 2019 to assume office in January 2020, she subsequently won a contested election later in 2020 to retain her seat—becoming both the first Native American to sit on Washington’s high court and the first Native person in the state to win a statewide election.
An enrolled tribal member of the Pueblo of Isleta and a descendant of the Pueblo of Laguna, both in New Mexico, Justice Montoya-Lewis earned both a law degree and a Master of Social Work from the University of Washington prior to serving on tribal courts and on the Whatcom County Superior Court.
What Did Justice Montoya-Lewis Say About the “Highs” and “Lows” of Her Term?
Reflecting on her time on the bench in a recent interview, Justice Montoya-Lewis said the “highs” of serving on the Washington State Supreme Court included having the opportunity to write majority opinions on subjects close to her heart. Conversely, she described the “lows” as the weight of “carrying the hopes and dreams of a whole community” alongside feelings of isolation.
Elaborating on that sense of isolation on the nine-member court, Justice Montoya-Lewis said: “It can be quite lonely to be the only person in the room that has a real understanding of what your experience in the world is, and I have found that to be constantly challenging.”
How Did She Shape Jurisprudence on the Indian Child Welfare Act?
Early in her Supreme Court tenure, Justice Montoya-Lewis was selected at random to author an opinion in a case involving the federal Indian Child Welfare Act. That assignment made her the first Native American appellate judge to guide the use of the federal statute, which she wrote was “enacted to remedy the historical and persistent state-sponsored destruction of Native families and communities.”
What Disagreements Over Court Traditions and Clerk Footnotes Emerged?
Justice Montoya-Lewis noted that she experienced differences with some of her fellow justices regarding certain traditions and protocols of the state Supreme Court. In recent years, she began publicly thanking individual law clerks by name in footnotes to her judicial opinions.
Explaining her reasoning, Justice Montoya-Lewis said: “We depend a lot on our staff. In my culture, it is expected that you thank the people who help you.”
Other members of the court, including now-retired Justice Barbara Madsen, expressed discomfort with naming specific staff members in that manner, stating they did not want individuals singled out.
How Did the Dispute Play Out in the Climate Commitment Act Opinion?
According to Justice Montoya-Lewis, tensions over the practice came to a head in the spring of 2026 when she authored the majority opinion upholding an aspect of Washington’s Climate Commitment Act. Some of her colleagues indicated they would instead write or sign a concurring opinion if her majority draft retained the footnote thanking her law clerk.
Justice Montoya-Lewis said that situation led her to send an internal memorandum stating: “I would remove the footnote at this point, given that there was the risk of losing the opinion. And I believe I said, ‘If there’s any question about why I’m not running for re-election, this is part of the answer.’”
In a concurring opinion, Justice Steven González wrote: “I understand why some justices object to thanking a staff member in an opinion.” He added: “I lament that we are not flexible enough to support a different cultural tradition.”
In her own concurrence, Justice Madsen said she disagreed with singling out individuals in that way because doing so could create confusion, arguing that the court should speak “with one voice” in majority rulings. Justice Madsen wrote: “In my view, a majority opinion should reflect the judgment of the court as a whole rather than emphasize any one individual’s contribution.”
Summing up the exchange, Justice Montoya-Lewis described it as a “minor but good example of how challenging it is to be heard when your voice is really different.”
How Did the Court Address the 1916 Alec Towessnute Fishing Rights Ruling?
While noting frustration with the court’s slow and incremental pace—as well as internal debates and external criticism from conservatives during the recent campaign season alleging a lack of “ideological diversity,” even as she pointed to “heated discussions” and strong differences among the nine justices after oral arguments—Justice Montoya-Lewis highlighted significant institutional actions taken during her tenure.
One such action involved revisiting a 1916 Washington State Supreme Court decision concerning tribal fishing rights in the case of Alec Towessnute, a Yakama Nation member who had been arrested for fishing he maintained was protected by treaty rights. In 1916, the court not only affirmed his conviction but included language in the ruling from a justice that questioned the right of Native people to exist.
At the request of Mr Towessnute’s family and then-Attorney General Bob Ferguson, among others, Justice Montoya-Lewis pushed for the court to repudiate that earlier decision.
Recalling that effort, Justice Montoya-Lewis said: “It was very unusual to be asked to do something that didn’t come to the court through a case, but I strenuously argued that we should take the opportunity to say we repudiate not just that conviction, but the beliefs that gave rise to that conviction.”
The Washington State Supreme Court formally took that step in 2020.
What Are Justice Montoya-Lewis’s Views on Precedent, Future Cases, and Her Next Steps?
Asked about how a future court might rule if presented with a so-called “millionaire’s tax” or income tax on high earners, Justice Montoya-Lewis said she makes no predictions.
“I hoped I would get better and better at prediction, and I’ve honestly gotten worse because we all grow and change, and each case is really different,” she said.
Any future challenge involving a graduated or high-earner income tax under Washington’s constitution would confront the 1933 Culliton precedent, which defined income as property and established a constitutional barrier to graduated income taxes in the state.
Discussing her approach to legal precedent more broadly, Justice Montoya-Lewis said she sometimes grapples with how past decisions bind later courts. “It’s the basis of our system. What came before is what dictates what happens next or what happens in the future,” she said, adding that while she studies precedents, she is not “wedded” to them “because I have a great deal of skepticism about whether those decisions are just.”
Following her departure, Justice Montoya-Lewis plans to work with the American Indian Law Center at the University of New Mexico—whose pre-law boot camp she attended years ago and described as something that “changed my life”—to help expand the pipeline of Native American law clerks and future judges. She also hopes to write a memoir exploring her family’s history, including relatives who were forced to attend the Carlisle Indian Industrial School in Pennsylvania, where she visited her great aunt’s burial site in July 2026.
With her exit, the Supreme Court will no longer have a Native American justice on the bench, with King County Superior Court Judge Jaime Hawk set to fill the seat.
“I think it’s a loss for tribal communities,” Justice Montoya-Lewis said. “But I also think we have made commitments in our opinions and in a public way to recognize that our system has not been fair to those communities, and I think we’ve made a public commitment to not allow that to continue. So I hope that my colleagues hold each other accountable to that.”
Background: Tribal Rights, Judicial Precedent, and Turnover on Washington’s High Court
Washington’s Supreme Court consists of nine justices elected to staggered six-year terms on a nonpartisan ballot, with candidates running for numbered positions and vacancies between elections historically filled by gubernatorial appointment before voters contest the seat. Justice Montoya-Lewis’s arrival in 2020 marked a milestone in the court’s composition—the first time a Native American sat on the state’s highest court—during a period marked by heightened attention to tribal treaty rights, state climate legislation such as the Climate Commitment Act, and debates over judicial representation and constitutional interpretation.
In Washington constitutional law, the 1933 Culliton v. Chase decision has long served as a central point of legal debate whenever proposals for graduated or high-income taxes arise, because the court held that income constitutes property under the state constitution and therefore cannot be taxed at progressive rates without constitutional amendment or a re-examination of precedent. Meanwhile, federal Indian boarding school history—exemplified by institutions such as the Carlisle Indian Industrial School in Pennsylvania—and the federal Indian Child Welfare Act remain foundational touchstones for Indigenous legal history and family law across the United States.
Predictions: How Could Justice Montoya-Lewis’s Departure Affect Tribal Communities, Legal Pipelines, and Future Court Rulings?
- Tribal Nations and Indigenous Litigants: Without a Native American justice on the nine-member bench once Justice Montoya-Lewis steps down, tribal governments and Indigenous litigants will look to existing institutional commitments, treaty and statutory frameworks, and judicial accountability to maintain attention to tribal sovereignty, child welfare, and historical fairness in appellate proceedings.
- Aspiring Native American Lawyers and Judicial Candidates: Justice Montoya-Lewis’s planned work with the American Indian Law Center at the University of New Mexico and her prospective family memoir may bolster mentorship, pre-law preparation, and awareness of career pathways into appellate clerkships and the judiciary for future Native American law students.
- Future Constitutional and Tax Litigation: With incoming Justice Jaime Hawk and the remaining bench presiding over future dockets, any legal dispute testing the 1933 Culliton precedent or a proposed high-earner income tax—as well as ongoing administrative and statutory appeals before the court—will be shaped by how individual justices weigh stare decisis, constitutional text, and changing legal arguments on a case-by-case basis.